A while back, I wrote an article ("Deaf Rattles") about the 'Versus' culture in comics and nerd media and the YouTube series Death Battle and the various issues I end up having with the concept. In that article I recall an old issue of Dragon magazine that proposed and worked through a battle between Raistlin and Elminster and how that may go down and how much I enjoyed the concept then. Of course, my article hardly set the internet on fire and the whole Versus culture continues unabated.
Rather than complain though (well, maybe a little), I've decided to be the change I want to see in the fandom and start doing my own version of versus battles here in my tiny and quiet corner of the internet. Hopefully my regular readers will enjoy what I'm trying to do here and we have a bit of fun along the way. Unlike the big sites, I'll be trying to focus on indy and lesser-known characters where I can, and trying to stay within how they're represented and written in their source material. First up, let's do some Anime and Indy Comics.
Ogre Vs Luther Strode
One is the Strongest Creature on Earth, Yuujirou Hanma, The Ogre, the other is an urban legend, the greatest Disciple of Cain, Luther Strode. Both men bathe in combat and violence to a level that has made them living myths, virtual bogeymen who leave nothing but death in their wakes. Both are unarmed combatants par excellence, having pushed their bodies and minds to superhuman levels, conventional weapons are basically useless against them and there are few in the world who could hope to challenge their might. What would happen if these two masters of violence came to blows? Let's find out!
Yuujirou Hanma
Known as Ogre, Yuujirou Hanma is the Strongest Creature on Earth, a veteran of countless wars, master of many martial arts techniques and never defeated in battle. Due to the nature of how strength and fighting prowess are represented in the Baki series, quantifying just how strong Ogre is is pretty tricky. Whilst some of his feats, including punching an elephant the size of a house to death with one blow and being so fast on his feet that people can't see his movements, boarder on the superhuman, within his own setting, he represents the limits of human potential, rather than being a genuine superman. That said, as well as astounding physical feats, Yuujirou can manipulate his aura to terrify or enrage people around him and can assess the strength of his foes with sight and scent. Also frustrating for quantifying Ogre's abilities is the fact that he rarely actually fights anyone in the series, dispatching most of his opponents in one or two strikes. His fight with Baki is probably the only time we get a good idea of his limits, and even then, he's not fighting at full strength for most of the battle.
Luther Strode
Once a skinny teenage boy who was bullied at school, Luther's life changed when he ordered an exercise programme from a comic book and discovered The System, becoming a disciple of Cain. Luther quickly became an artisan of murder, a superhuman killer who was virtually unstoppable by conventional means. Able to resist the, now-constant, urge to kill somehow, Luther started on a crusade to end the legacy of Cain and use his powers for good. Luther is strong enough to bend steel and punch through people with his bare hands. Perfect conscious control over his body grants Luther resistance to damage up to and including small arms fire (he can "catch" bullets in his muscle fibers), accelerated healing and the ability to "switch off" pain and physical limitations. The System enables Luther to predict his opponent's moves before they happen, as well as spotting weakness and injuries. Unlike other disciples of Cain, Luther has passed beyond the primal urge to murder and has achieved an enlightened state through physical perfection, making him an equal of Cain himself.
Why We Fight
Thankfully, the narrative reasons for Ogre and Luther to fight are pretty solid and straightforward. Ogre is a mercenary and Luther is a wanted criminal with a fearsome reputation, so it's possible that he could be hired to bring Luther in or just kill him. Conversely, Ogre's abilities and reputation could conceivably lead Luther to believe he's a disciple of Cain and therefore want to hunt him down to either recruit or stop. Despite both of their lethal reputations, it's not guaranteed that the fight will be to the death, as Luther tries to avoid killing if possible and Ogre only kills when he has to or is being paid to, preferring to stun or cripple if he believes the opponent is beneath him. Luther is more likely than Ogre to try and avoid civilian casualties, but neither is going to start hurting non-combatants around them just to gain an advantage, either.
How Ogre Wins
Out of the two combatants, Yuujirou is the most likely to escalate the fight faster if he feels he has to. Luther fights reactively, only moving to lethal force to defend himself from the same, so if Ogre goes straight to his most powerful techniques, he has a decent chance of putting Luther down before he gets going. It all comes down to how fast Ogre can identify Luther as a serious threat (remembering he didn't think Baki was a threat until well into their fight). With his abilities to sense strength, it's pretty possible that Ogre will know to be serious from the outset, with the only caveat to this being that he rarely gets a serious fight, so the desire to really test himself may get the better of him. Ogre is also more willing to kill than Luther, so if he can get in a finishing blow first, he may get the better of Luther's healing.
How Luther Wins
Luther's main advantages in this fight are his ability to sustain levels of damage that would kill most people and his history of fighting people with the same or similar abilities to him. Despite his strength, most of Ogre's attacks probably won't hurt Luther all that much and his recovery abilities will give Luther the higher level of stamina in this fight. Unless Ogre starts trying to kill, Luther will be attempting to talk him down (which won't work) or just incapacitate him as fast as possible. If Luther can withstand Ogre's attacks for long enough, he gets into a good position to win, especially once he's taking the fight seriously enough to start predicting Ogre's blows. Luther may also be able to access help from Petra and other turned Disciples, which means he has more to draw on if the fight turns against him.
Well, that's the first one of these down, I have at least two more in the pipeline, so let me know if you enjoyed this and what you think about reading more.














