Superhero Media: Punisher War Zone (2008)

Before Frank Castle got his own Netflix series, the big argument between fans was which film was better, the '80s version, The Punisher from 2004 and Punisher War Zone. As you probably know by now, the Tom Jane version is my personal pick, but for a while War Zone was the favourite of many. Filled with stars of television, War Zone appears more to be an elaborate pilot for a cable series than it does the start of a new film franchise. In recent years, War Zone has become something of a cult darling, with the director, Lexi Alexander, doing a series of interviews in which she discusses the misogyny and obligations of the Hollywood studio system and how that came to impact the film. It's fascinating, but fails to distract from the fact that the film still didn't turn out all that great. Not that I'm implying that Alexander is a bad filmmaker, just that an interesting story doesn't always make an uninteresting film more engaging. Still, at least Frank shoots a lot of people and wears a skull shirt for most of the run time.

Taking a great deal of "inspiration" from the Garth Ennis The Punisher MAX run I've discussed before, War Zone is full of references to those comics, or at least pretends to be. You know how the 2017 Ghost In The Shell makes a lot of reference to previous iterations of the franchise, but they don't really mean anything? Same here. Sure, it's great to see Christu and Tiberu from "The Slavers", but their inclusion doesn't make any sense and they're just there to be a reference; same with a name-only version of Maginty from "Kitchen Irish", who, in War Zone is a freerunner on a constant meth high. That's not to say that there isn't a lot in War Zone to enjoy, it certainly does play like a Punisher story, with plenty of kills, a variety of guns and a nice bit of gore. The big fight just before the finale is reminiscent of The Raid or Dredd, taking place in an abandoned hotel, with Frank murdering his way through ranks of goons to get to Jigsaw and the plot device hostages in the penthouse. It's really well done and just a good action sequence to check out.

One thing I've noticed about the best Punisher stories is that there tends to be a character other than Frank who is eating up a lot of the plot. This is typically a good thing, as Frank doesn't have a lot of room for growth and tends to not have an arc of any discernible kind, so people have to react around him, rather than him reacting to them. Think Agent Carter in Captain America The First Avenger or anyone in Superman The Movie. War Zone dose have a few characters that exist around Frank, but only really the antagonist, Jigsaw, actually undergoes much change in reaction to Frank's actions; it's just not a brilliantly-written film, sorry. Again, this really feels like the kind of "movie-length" television pilot that was common for genre programming in the 1990s, and the cast being drawn from programmes such as Rome, Dexter and Lost tends to just reinforce that notion. If War Zone is your favourite Punisher film, I really can't fault you, but it just leaves me cold and wanting Tom Jane to return.